Tuesday, March 8, 2011

I=Me. You=Caregiver




According to Lacan, an infant cannot create an identity for themselves at birth. The child’s image resides in the mother, since the child has not seen itself. In addition to this, the child’s only concern is the need for food and comfort. Therefore, the caregiver becomes the ideal “self” for the child.  What is essential for development of the child’s identity is the need for eventual separation. Separation, as defined by Lacan, is the creation of the self by distancing oneself from the caregiver.  Since birth, the child creates a bond with the caregiver—and will continue to depend on the caregiver if separation is not achieved.
Lacan goes on to state that there are three basic principles of the mind: the real, the imaginary, and the symbolic.  The symbolic is the formation of the word “I” and the creation of the self. The real is the creation of the self-sufficient self, where there is no need for the caregiver, because the self can fulfill the needs. The imaginary is experienced during what Lacan describes is the Mirror Stage. During infancy, when a child comes into contact with a mirror they create a misrecognized image of itself. The subconscious creates the “I” identity with the image in the mirror. This, as Lacan describes, is a false understanding of the self. And, although the ego is satisfied with the image of the self, the overall consciousness cannot create a relationship with the imaginary image of the self. As a society, we insist that children should play with toys that have mirrors in them so that they can begin to recognize themselves. Yet, as Lacan explains, the recognition of the self is not reliant on the image but rather the subconscious ability to fulfill the needs of the id.



Tuesday, March 1, 2011

Structuralizing van (Analysis 2)


The man to the left is not only mourning his youth but also his decisions. She, a young girl of sixteen, doesn’t love the man in black. She is also not of nobility and is, instead, marrying into it. The house they are waiting in is not theirs but his mother’s—her mother in law’s. He is awaiting his mother’s decision of what royal position he will be anointed. She doesn’t care what position he gets, just as long as the money is stable and he is gone. The child she is carrying is unwanted by him but beloved by her. She had always wanted a child, but being that she is not of high class she, until now, hadn’t found a right suitor. 

According to the theory of Structuralism, the signs and symbols of a particular text can determine its meaning (1088). Looking at the painting, The Arnolfini Wedding, by Jan van Eych, with a structuralism lens many things will be uncovered. First off, by looking at the clothes, it can be determined that this painting is set during the Renaissance.  Also, by looking at the décor around the two characters it can be said that the characters come from money. Additionally, there is a sense of piety, or extreme religious devotion. The woman is covering her hair as many women of that time did in order to show their love for God. Furthermore, on the subject of religion, the mirror that is behind the couple is made of wood with several carving etched into the frame. Each circle within the frame has a different religious picture, and most of which are circling around the crucifixion of Jesus. Since this mirror is hanging over the “marital’ bed of sorts, it can be inferred that perhaps they are abiding by the religious laws of marriage, and following the Bible by procreating while consensually married. Also, in the mirror, the image of two other people other than the two main characters in our picture. There is a woman in a blue and white maid’s dress and another gentleman. This suggests that the pregnancy of the woman is being watched over and cared about. Ultimately, this painting is a sign of the time period in which it is set in and painted in.

 

Leitch, Vincent B. et al., ed. The Norton Anthology of Theory and Criticism. New York: Norton,
2001. Print.
Painting: Jan Van Eych, The Arnolfini Wedding. 1434. 

Words may Equal Images



According to Saussure, in his “Course in General Linguistics,” words and letters are signs. In our community, words signify the image of the object. The word tree automatically conjures up a picture of a tree in everyone’s mind.  However, the word to image connection is completely arbitrary. What this means is, the word tree is completely subjective to culture. We have developed the word Tree, yet in other cultures a different word would signify the same image. Take Spanish for example, arbol is Spanish for tree. Yet, like in English it signifies the a tree that is not a palm tree or cactus. Nevertheless, if said to someone, an image of a tree would emerge in their mind. 



The major issue with the signifier and the signified is the fact that a particular word may not induce the same image in everyone’s mind. Since the word to image concept is arbitrarily based, we are effected by our surroundings and associations. Cat, for example, may create different images or thoughts in everyone’s mind. I may think of my cat, whereas someone may think of their own, or jungle cat, or some crazy cat that attacked them when they were a child. Perhaps, even the word cat may not even create an image in the mind of the listener. This is where language is dependant of the social aspect of life. Someone who has never seen a cat may not have a tangible image in their mind—and would instead depend on the other adjectives the writer or speaker uses to create the image in their mind. 


Tuesday, February 22, 2011

Art is not a handicraft, it is the transmission of feeling the artist has experienced. --Leo Tolstoy

According to Shklovsky, the technique of art is to make the familiar “unfamiliar.”  But what does that mean? Shklovsky says that in a life that has become “habitualized.” We, as a societal whole, are constantly doing the same tasks over and over again—all the while having the same fears and worries etc. So, how does an artist make the everyday task new? Shklovsky would say that the artist would have to describe or portray the “familiar object” in an unheard way. He would go on to say that writers like Tolstoy have mastered this art in his extremely long novels.
Yet, the most important part to remember—and quite possibly the only way to achieve defamiliarization—is that the object itself is irrelevant. What is important is the way the writer evokes emotion or thought from the presence of that object in the work. As Shklovsky states, Tolstoy had mastered—with the help of his lengthy descriptions—new ways to describe even the mundane. Shklovsky uses Tolstoy’s description of the theater to demonstrate Tolstoy’s unique use of defamiliarization.
The middle of the stage consisted of flat boards; by the sides stood painted pictures representing trees, and at the back a linen cloth was stretched down to the floorboards. Maidens in red bodices and white skirts sat on the middle of the stage. One, very fat, in a white silk dress, sat apart on a narrow bench to which a green pasteboard box was glued from behind. They were all singing something. When they had finished, the maiden in white approached the prompter's box. A man in silk with tight-fitting pants on his fat legs approached her with a plume and began to sing and spread his arms in dismay. The man in the tight pants finished his song alone; then the girl sang. After that both remained silent as the music resounded; and the man, obviously waiting to begin singing his part with her again, began to run his fingers over the hand of the girl in the white dress. They finished their song together, and everyone in the theater began to clap and shout. But the men and women on stage, who represented lovers, started to bow, smiling and raising their hands.
Everyone has seen a theater, and it is very difficult to evoke any type of particular emotion when describing a theater. However, Tolstoy uses such vivid detail to paint his image that it is almost impossible to not see what he’s talking about. Instead of saying, the in the theater stood two people and they sang, he uses elaborate language. Ultimately, he defamiliarizes a very familiar scene—something Shklovsky desired to see more of in literature. It begs the question, however, what would Shklovsky think of Proust? In my opinion, I think he would appreciate Proust’s extreme detail and eventual defamiliarization of everything—even butter cookies.

Work Cited 
Shklovsk, Viktor. "Art as Technique." web. 22 Feb. 2011 

Tuesday, February 15, 2011

Patton and Rhetoric (Analysis 1)



            This clip is from the 1970s Francis Ford Coppola film, Patton. George C. Scott plays the unforgettable WWII General, George Patton. This speech is modeled after an actual speech Patton delivered in June of 1944 in an unrecorded place in England. For the movie, the screen writers and Coppola cleaned up the expletives that were used in the original speech, due to the unknown protest and potential misinterpretation in the context of the film.
            According to the Aristotelian Rhetorical speech model, Patton’s speech can be considered to be categorized under the “deliberate” type of speech. This speech, in the film, was meant to excite and persuade the listeners into taking action during World War Two. Patton was considered to be of strong military background and an inspirational speaker for the men who had been drafted into the war.
Patton begins his speech with a short syllogism—“… no bastard ever won a war by dying for his country. He won it by making the other poor dumb bastard die for his country.” The next short syllogism is, “Americans love a winner and will not tolerate a loser.” And the final short syllogism is, “the Nazis are the enemy.” All of these syllogisms lead to the enthymeme of: the Nazis are the enemy and it is our job as Americans to, not only participate, but to win the battle against the Nazis. Or what can be stated another way as: Americans are winners, Nazis are un-American; therefore, Nazis could only lose, never win.  
            In addition to the very persuasive enthymeme, Patton also uses many different language techniques to be as convincing as possible. First and the most used was pathos-laced language. The most often used emotion used throughout the speech is anger. He uses the idea that losing in this war is an intolerable outcome, and that if it were to happen it would never be accepted, “…Americans have never lost and will never lose a war because the very thought is hateful to Americans.” He continues to say that due to our natural ability and hunger for victory he “pities the bastards,” because we are going into battle with the desire to “spill their blood” and “shoot them in the belly.” And the most infamous line filled with the most emotion is, “We’re not just going to shoot the bastards, we’re going to cut out their living guts and use them to grease the treads of our tanks.” These words are very emotionally powerful, and were used in this instance to stimulate the soldiers in war.    
            In the end, the use of these powerful words and commanding enthymeme are influenced heavily by Patton’s use of the two of the three important qualities of an effective Aristotelian speaker. First was his employment of eunoia—acting the part. At the time of WWII  Patton was an older gentleman, and had been recognized for his impeccable leadership skills. Therefore, in the film we first see Patton dressed in army fatigues giving directions—“Ten-hut. Be Seated.” Being that he is a General in the U.S. Army, if he had come onto the stage saying, “hello folks” the soldiers wouldn’t have taken him seriously.  
In addition to Eunoia, he also used Arête language. Patton’s language eluded that his intentions were to better the world. He used several phrases to elude to the fact that he was of good character and the opposition was not. However, one sentence in particular encapsulates his entire view of the war. It follows immediately after the question of what will happen if a soldier finds himself unsure if he can fight or not. His answer is, “The Nazis are the enemy…When you put your hand into a bunch of goo that was a moment before your best friend’s face, you’ll know what to do.” Some would view that war is an unnecessary brutality in the world; however, Patton refutes this by saying that the Nazis will kill, and that it is our job to end the violence. It is not a matter of whether it’s wrong, but rather, in this instance, if the victory will better the world.
            Ultimately, Patton’s speech in the film is filled with very emotional, or pathos, language. It was meant to persuade the men in the military to go into war wholeheartedly, knowing that their sacrifices will have a positive effect. The speech was, in the end, very influential with the use of the very basic Aristotelian models of rhetoric and that of a ethical rhetorical speaker.

 Works Cited
Farago, Ladislas. "Patton Script - Transcript from the Screenplay And/or George C. Scott
Movie." Drew's Script-O-Rama: Free Movie Scripts and Screenplays, Baby! Web. 111
Feb. 2011.
Leitch, Vincent B. et al., ed. The Norton Anthology of Theory and Criticism. New York: Norton,
2001. Print.
Province, Charles M. "The Famous Patton Speech." Patton Society Homepage. Web. 10 Feb.
2011.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Plato and the Cave of Questions


            Of course, Plato would have a cave in which prisoners of sorts would be held against their will and shown only shadows. I say of course, because, in his philosophy, everything was in fact a mere imitation. A replication, a shadow. And to have seen the object in its true form was something we, as puny humans, simply could not do. His philosophical story/question, from what I gather, is this, can we really use words to describe something that is in fact intangible? And if we use these words to imitate the imitated, can those words be trusted as truth?
            
           Being a narrative writer, and a novice poet, I was immediately and selfishly offended. How could he question the use of a word; a word that was so carefully chosen by the writer? In short, his quick dismissal and scrutiny of these creative words was really irking me. But why? Why was I so hung up on some centuries old philosophy? Then, I thought, was there really some truth to this Cave business? Are we really just the audience in a higher order’s puppet show? All these questions flooded my mind, cutting off the circulation to the vocabulary parts of my brain. Why were we choosing certain words? Was there something to this idea that words are really meaningless? Or rather, that words are misleading. I thought back to all of the Shakespeare I’ve read; and the beautiful poetry the Bronte sisters published; and the stunning novels about war and coming of age. I’m sure that Plato wouldn’t have had a very profound love for these texts, as I do. But was owning and claiming the Writer title synonymous with the Liar title? 

            I’m still unsure about the truth of words. I can’t wrap my mind around the concept of words being nothing more than arbitrary sounds and letters stigmatized with definitions and connotations. And that these “definitions” are used to convey misconceptions, or inaccurate descriptions of something so indescribable. Perhaps more reading of Plato’s Republic will clarify or resolve this conflict I’m having.

Hermaneutics--From Herman to the Bible

I had heard the word Hermeneutics before, but I never really knew what it meant. Whenever the word came up in conversation with my intellectual superiors, Herman Munster’s face flashed in my mind. And when it was introduced on the first day, one thought came to mind—I was going to be thoroughly horse whipped. But alas, I’m starting to really understand what the whole business of Hermeneutics is—and in fact, it has nothing to do with the Munsters at all.

When first grappling with the idea that Hermeneutics was just the study and interpretation of a work based on what and how ‘something’ is portrayed, I was more confused than ever. What did it all mean, literally? I was, to put it lightly, scared. Great, I thought, this is what we’re starting off with. I would need a whole semester to analyze all the possible answers for the one question that so condescendingly hung over my head—why? In fiction there are innumerable symbols and hidden messages cleverly hidden beneath the words, stuck somewhere in limbo between the grains of the paper and the dots of black ink. And it was now, as I understand, my job to find all of those messages beneath the sand and, without any hesitation answer the why. But first, to uncover the why, I must first discover and understand the how.

Hermeneutics, as I comprehend, is using the how (i.e. how a conversation is had, how an element is portrayed, and so on), to get to the why. Why did the author write it that particular way? And in my reading of this subject I ran across Bible Hermeneutics.  In short, the interpretation of the Bible. I wouldn’t know where to begin in exploring every symbolic detail in the Bible, but it did capture my curiosity. As I did a little research on the appropriately called Biblical exegesis, I found that Hermeneutics is considered to be a ‘philosophy’ of sorts. And even though it has been a socially accepted form of interpretation for sacred works, it cannot be misconstrued for truth.

So, in the end, I found that like Herman Munster, Hermeneutics could simply just be an important character. And even though theories are only theories, I realized that Hermeneutics can be considered the ‘umbrella’ to which all other theories flock under.